Welcome to Casey's, a gem nestled at 270 Crossing Dr, Sherman, IL. Not just your ordinary pizza delivery spot, Casey's seamlessly blends convenience with quality, making it a favorite among locals and travelers alike. Picture this: a bustling gas station where the aroma of freshly baked pizza coalesces with sweet-scented cookies, creating an inviting atmosphere perfect for a pit stop. In fact, it's well-loved by many, including a customer named Gary, who describes it as a "nice pit stop for gas fill-up," praising their delicious pizza and breakfast options.
What truly sets Casey's apart is its assortment of delightful offerings. From their BBQ Chicken Pizza—a deliciously smoky creation crowned with grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and mozzarella, to the Ultimate Waffle Breakfast Sandwich featuring layers of savory sausage and eggs snugly wrapped in warm maple waffles, there's something to satiate every craving. The chef's tip? Add banana peppers to the BBQ Chicken Pizza for an explosion of flavor!
But don't overlook their delectable desserts. The Caramel Chocolate Pecan Cookie will sweep you off your feet with its rich, flavorful profile. And if you’re in the mood for a familiar classic, indulge in their baker-style Chocolate Chip Cookies. They’re the perfect shareable treat to accompany your meal or enjoy on their own.
Beyond the food, the exceptional service at Casey's truly shines. Customers like Lorie S highlight the staff's dedication to customer satisfaction, ensuring that mishaps are swiftly resolved with a smile. And it's heartwarming anecdotes like Carly Camel's that illuminate Casey's community spirit when the staff went above and beyond to help during a storm.
In your next culinary adventure, whether you’re picking up a late-night snack or fueling up for a road trip, consider making Casey’s your destination. Here, quality meets convenience, and each bite is infused with warmth—both in flavor and customer care. So why wait? Next time you're in or near Sherman, IL, be sure to stop in for a memorable meal and a friendly service you won't forget!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
211 Main St Suite 3, Winooski, VT 05404, United States
2854 Pocatello Ave, American Falls, ID 83211, United States
Park Beach Plaza, Shop 76/253 Pacific Hwy, Coffs Harbour NSW 2450, Australia
976 Lasalle Blvd, Greater Sudbury, ON P3A 3C9, Canada
KH-16, Jl. Tenggilis Mejoyo, Kali Rungkut, Rungkut, Surabaya, East Java 60283, Indonesia
Gary
16/10/2025
Nice pit stop for gas fill-up and just down the road from Interstate 55. Usual good tasting Casey's pizza, breakfast pizza, burgers, breakfast sandwiches, snacks, drinks of all kinds and good donuts. Restrooms are available and some automotive needs are here, also some medicines for headache, etc...
Carly Camel
22/09/2025
A HUGE thank you to Casey’s gas station in Sherman!!!! The kids and I stopped there when the sirens were going off. Told us to get in the beer cooler. And gave them new shirts to keep them warm. Also any hot food they wanted since they would have to get rid of it since the power went out. THANK YOU SHERMAN CASEYS!!!!
Lorie S
15/09/2025
A door dash employee picked up our order and wasn’t supposed to. The employees at Casey’s did anything and everything to make it right. I would have given more stars if possible. Very impressed and recommend them, just don’t use door dash.
Jenny
05/09/2025
Lisa is a life saver! What wonderful customer service. I will never forget your kindness toward my daughter!!!! She will see you again soon :)
Jimmy Howell
12/08/2025
This is the most awesome place that I've ever been and we just now landed in my truck is shortly behind me I am really enjoying getting away from Oklahoma City LOL if anybody sees my wife Tammy tell her I said I love her
Laura Moore
04/08/2025
I noted and was impressed by the number of pizzas being carried from the Casey's in Sherman, Illinois. This follows with other's evaluations. I used the restroom; it was not up to cleanliness par.